Home / The catalog / One Too Many Film · 1985 · Drama, Family, TV film One Too ManyNo ratings yet. Be the first to rate it. Four high school friends find their lives changed forever when one of the friends drives drunk with devastating results.Rate One Too Many Cast and crewPeter Horton DirectorBruce Harmon WriterMichelle Pfeiffer AnnieVal Kilmer EricMare Winningham BethLance Guest TimGrace Zabriskie Mrs. LintonMichael Ensign Mr. GreyLeo Rossi Mr. Jenkins